ENVIRO NOTES: Finding balance in the forest

Gulf widens between environmentalists, industrialists

Canada’s boreal forest stretches all the way from the Yukon/Alaska border in the west to the eastern shore of Newfoundland.

It’s made up of trembling aspen, white birch, balsam fir, jack pine, black and white spruce, for the most part. Northwards, it merges into the sub-arctic taiga and tundra; in the south, it gives way to grassland or mixed woodlands. It covers almost six million square kilometres and has been rated as “one of the world’s greatest treasures,” along with its Siberian counterpart and the Amazon rainforest.

The International Boreal Conservation Science Panel met recently in Baltimore and came out with the assertion that half of the total area should be protected from industrial developments because of its ecological significance and value as a massive carbon depository.

The panel estimated that about one-eighth had already been adversely impacted by industrial developments – forestry, by which they mean timber harvesting, mining and oil and gas exploration.

The only activity that the panel would accept is traditional hunting by aboriginal peoples (does ‘traditional’ exclude ATVs, high-powered rifles and skidoos?) and there should be co-management.

This position, taken by a group of eminent biologists and environmentalists, looks at the ecological significance of the area and presents one side of an argument, thus clearly illustrating the philosophical gulf between conservationist and industrialists that presents governments with a difficult dilemma.

What might be the local and national economic benefits of permitting some development, and what might be the environmental costs? What measure of environmental harm, if any, is acceptable in the short and long terms? What constraints on development could be enforced, not just written, to minimize environmentally harmful impacts without compromising the viability of a project? How and by whom should decisions be made? What time frames should be envisaged? Whose interests are predominant?

These difficult questions should be addressed in open debate using science, facts and data, rather than rhetoric and unsupported hyperbole.

Think back a century and imagine a discussion on whether one could approve the conversion of prairie grasslands to wheat fields, a significant ecological and social change.

The social impact was immediate, alteration of habitat proved harmful to bison, burrowing owls, many other creatures and a way of life; national benefit came slowly.

How would a benefit/cost analysis have looked then and how would it compare with one today?

Can we embark on a similar examination of the pros and cons of possible industrial ventures in our pristine boreal forest?

It is particularly challenging when some of the values are difficult or impossible to quantify – can you put a dollar value on clean water, the last golden eagle?

What are the lost opportunity costs if development is not sanctioned? How does one apply the law of unexpected consequences?

There is no magic formula that will provide an answer. When all the issues have been explored and debated, the eventual decision will reflect the bias of the decision-makers and, whatever the outcome, it is unlikely to please all of the protagonists.

Only time will tell if it was the right solution.

Dr. Roy Strang writes monthly on the environment for the Peace Arch News. rmstrang@shaw.ca


Just Posted

House fire in South Surrey

Emergency crews seen racing towards 160 Street and 28 Avenue

FOCUS: New arena, more ice in Surrey – but will it be enough for everyone?

With both rinks to close at North Surrey rec, the result is a net gain of one ice sheet this fall

Pair of men charged in three robberies in Surrey, Delta

Charged are Karmal Singh Grewal, 26, of Vancouver and Gursimran Sahota, 21, of Surrey

Watchdog called after man who yelled racial slurs at Surrey vigil hurt during arrest

BC RCMP say man was ‘acting suspiciously’ at prayer vigil for victims of New Zealand mosque shootings

Two suspects sought after man shot in Surrey’s Hawthorne Park Sunday

Police say victim was arrested after being treated for gunshot in hospital

VIDEO: RCMP ask kids to help name soon-to-be police dogs

13 German shepherd puppies will be born this year

NDP’s Jagmeet Singh steps into the House of Commons, making history

Burnaby South MP becomes first visible minority to lead a federal party in the House of Commons

Chilliwack grad says modest dress codes don’t protect girls from assault

Sardis alumni was ‘catcalled, harassed, and groped by my male classmates’ despite modest clothing

One of the biggest cow shows in Canada is coming back to the ‘Wack

Prize money of $240,000 is on offer at the spring Holstein show Friday at Chilliwack Heritage Park

VIDEO: Race and sport examined at new We Are Hockey exhibit in Abbotsford

UFV SASI hosting exhibit looking at hockey history and race

Nearly 40% of British Columbians not taking their medications correctly: poll

Introduction of legal cannabis could cause more issues for drug interactions

Mining company fined $70,000 after two workers killed in B.C. truck crash

Broda Construction pleaded guilty to failing to provide safe workplace at Cranbrook rock quarry

B.C. argues it cannot stop Trans Mountain, but it can protect environment

Alberta Premier Rachel Notley says only Ottawa has the authority to decide what goes in trans-boundary pipelines

B.C. poverty plan combines existing spending, housing programs

Target is to lift 140,000 people out of poverty from 2016 level

Most Read

l -->