A judge has ordered that damages be paid to the owner of a third-floor condo in this building, following ‘beyond deficient’ renovations. (Google Streetview image)

$63,000 for failed White Rock renovation

Judge deems work on condo ‘beyond deficient’

A White Rock woman has been awarded more than $63,000 in damages in connection with home renovations a judge has described as “beyond deficient.”

“This is not simply a case where a corporate entity enters a contract to perform renovations, and those renovations are not done to the homeowner’s satisfaction,” Justice B.J. Brown concludes in reasons for judgment that were posted online Sept. 22.

“The failure in this case is so extreme as to amount to fraud.”

According to the court document, Deanna Mary Koltai sought damages against Dwayne Hauser and Hauser Custom Homes Ltd. in connection with renovations to a condo she bought on Vidal Street in December 2015.

She alleged breach of contract and negligence, claiming, among other things, that the defendants failed to perform the work properly and in a timely manner, failed to comply with regulations and removed a load-bearing wall without proper inspection or support.

Koltai told the court that the parties had a part-verbal, part-written agreement regarding who would do the work; Hauser’s expertise and oversight of the project; Hauser’s guarantee of quality, code compliance and fitness of the work; and that all necessary permits and authorizations would be obtained.

On that basis, they had agreed on a $84,997.50 project that was to be completed in April 2016.

Koltai told the court she paid $93,000, but that by mid-May 2016, it became apparent the work was not being performed to her satisfaction. She notified the defendants that she considered the contract breached; the following day, the defendants gave notice that no further work would be done on the renovation.

Koltai testified that she learned of problems with the project when a friend who went to the condo in late April to remove its stove and fridge reported to her that the renovation was “nowhere near completed and that it was a horrible disaster.”

She paid $58,000 to another contractor to complete the work. That individual testified that “all of the work was done inadequately and improperly,” Brown writes.

At trial, Hauser “acknowledged that the renovations did not go as planned,” Brown states.

He told the court he had advised Koltai of problems being experienced with the ceiling and floors, but that he did not expect them to be as extensive as they were.

“There were problems. He said that he felt like ‘we were getting in over our heads.’ He acknowledged that ‘I totally screwed up on this project,’” Brown writes.

Hauser submitted that he should not be personally liable for damages and that the contract had been with the company – for which he is the sole shareholder – only. Brown disagreed.

“He acknowledged that the whole job was unacceptably performed,” Brown states.

“He acknowledged that none of the work done would have passed code.”

She also notes that in cross-examination, Hauser said he did not tell Koltai “that he had been subject to nine different lawsuits or that he was paying off judgments.”

Brown found that the company breached the contract, and that Hauser was personally liable for damages.

Just Posted

Noted fiddlers bring kids to Surrey stage for ‘A Celtic Family Christmas’ concert

Bell theatre date for Natalie MacMaster and Donnell Leahy as they reunite for 23-city tour of Canada

Surrey/White Rock MLAs criticize, defend referendum on ‘most important question’

NDP MLA says ‘fear-mongering’ unwarranted; Liberals ‘frustrated’ by process

Surrey-based business donates $1M to hospital’s children centre improvements

Surrey Hospital Foundation kicks off campaign for ‘transformation’ of children’s centre

Surrey opera singer brings Mozart’s ‘Così fan tutte’ to Vancouver stage

Nancy Hasiuk-Lay has been hailed for her ‘sparkling and crystalline vocal tone’

North Delta family raising money for brain cancer treatment

23-year-old Tashina Janus and her family are raising funds to get her immunotherapy in the U.S.

Metro Vancouver mayors cancel Surrey LRT in favour of SkyTrain

Surrey mayor claims he can extend Skytrain for the $1.65 billion already committed to light rail

Hunter who saved B.C. man pinned inside smashed truck says ‘God was sending me to him’

Sayward man describes chance discovery of Duncan Moffat, 23, in northern Vancouver Island woods

Road-weary Canucks thumped 6-2 by Wild

Vancouver hosts the Montreal Canadiens on Saturday

Toronto private school didn’t report alleged sexual assault to police

Police say a sexual assault at an all-boys Catholic institution was not reported to them

China says butt out; Canada calls for release of “arbitrarily” detained Muslims

A Chinese foreign ministry spokeswoman accused Canada’s envoy of going beyond their diplomatic roles

Dead Saskatoon tattoo artist’s skin removed and preserved

The skin was removed in honour of the well known artist’s work

Lower Mainland couple missing in Thompson-Okanagan area

Barriere RCMP received a missing persons report for two senior overdue travellers

Vancouver Warriors cancel first 2 weeks of season as labour dispute continues

The announcement means games scheduled for Dec. 1 and Dec. 8 will no longer be played

B.C. Realtor suspended after helping intern forge note about sick grandma

Vancouver real estate agent Jaideep Singh Puri has to pay fine, take ethics course

Most Read

l -->