Lady Justice outside B.C. Supreme Court in New Westminster. (Photo: Tom Zytaruk)

Delta woman on hook for rollover crash after letting impaired man drive her rented car

The Insurance Corporation of B.C. doesn’t have to cover the bill, judge decides

A B.C . Supreme Court judge says the Insurance Corporation of B.C. doesn’t have to cover the substantial costs of a rollover car crash in which a rented car landed in a water-filled ditch in Delta, resulting in injury, because the renter had let an impaired driver get behind the wheel.

The case of Janelle Nastasia Sherrell v. ICBC was heard in New Westminster, with Justice Gordon Weatherill presiding. Sherrell took the insurance corporation to court after it denied her coverage on the basis she’s breached her policy under Section 55(5) of the Insurance (Vehicle) Regulation by permitting someone impaired by drugs or alcohol to drive the car.

She lost her case.

The court heard Sherrell, 31, rented a 2013 Mazda from Hertz Canada on Sept. 15, 2014, after her 2000 Honda Civic was impounded for 30 days.

She had been a passenger in her own car.

Sherrell testified that she believed at the time the reason her car had been impounded was because the driver didn’t have a valid BC driver’s licence. “She testified that she had learned later that the vehicle had been impounded because the driver was impaired by alcohol,” Weatherill noted.

Ten days into the impoundment, she rented the Mazda and her insurance policy on her Honda was rolled over to cover the rental car.

READ ALSO: ICBC’s boss says proposed insurance changes will leave two-thirds of B.C. drivers ‘better off’

On Oct. 5, 2014 she drove the Mazda to a friend’s home in Surrey, the court heard, where she “hung out” for about an hour before heading to her dad’s home in Delta, where she was living.

She testified she put her keys on a ledge inside the front door and then drank “at least six shots of Vodka,” threw up and blacked out. A group of friends had been there that night.

The court heard she drank until 4 a.m., when she and and a man named Vikramjit Singh Burgess headed out in the Mazda to buy two 26-0unce bottles of Vodka from an after-hours seller and returned home.

“She testified that she was intoxicated but that ‘Vik seemed to be fine’ and she permitted him to drive,” the judge noted. When they returned to her dad’s place, she said, she put the keys on the same ledge as before and in a short time downed about half of one bottle, straight from the bottle, until she was unconscious.

Sherrell testified she had no recollection of how much Burgess was drinking. Her next memory, she told the court, was waking up in the Mazda with Vik driving, seeing the speedometer at 160 km/h and then the Mazda hitting a ditch. Her then boyfriend, Jamie Ouellette, had been riding in the back seat and was injured in the crash.

Sherrell testified she had no recollection of getting into the car, where they were going and that Burgess “neither had her permission to drive the Mazda on that occasion nor had any standing permission to do so.”

Weatherill noted in his reasons for judgment that Burgess ultimately pleaded guilty to impaired driving causing bodily harm, that ICBC paid Ouellette $200,564.39 to settle his injury claim, and that ICBC has informed Sherrell it “intends to seek repayment of that amount from her.”

The court heard Sherrell gave a statement to Delta Police that “like I obviously shouldn’t have let him dr…drive that night.”

The constable asked her “do you remember a discussion of um, getting in the car, who was driving or anything like that when you, Jamie and um, Vik leave, just prior to the accident happening?”

The court heard she replied, “Yeah, he was, he was driving…and he had my keys…There was no way I was driving in that state. I had been drinking like all night.”

Weatherill found that ICBC “had established on the balance of probabilities that when the plaintiff permitted Vik to drive the Mazda, she knew he was intoxicated to the extent that he was incapable of operating a vehicle.”

Section 55(5) of the Insurance (Vehicle) Regulation states, under breach of conditions, that “An insured named in a certificate or additional product certificate must not permit the vehicle described in the certificate or additional product to be operated by a person or for a purpose that breaches a condition of this section.”

Meantime, ICBC revealed Thursday a net loss of $860 million in the first nine months of its current fiscal year, April 1 to Dec. 31, 2018, as litigated injury claims continue to escalate, and it is projecting a year-end net loss of $1.18 billion. The net claims incurred by ICBC for those first nine months were close to $5 billion, marking an increase of roughly $600 million over the same period the year prior.



tom.zytaruk@surreynowleader.com

Like us on Facebook Follow us on Instagram  and follow Tom on Twitter

Just Posted

55-year-old man taken to hospital after fire at Surrey RV park

Firefighters find man suffering from smoke inhalation, burns to face and hands: battalion chief

Coldest Night an event for warm hearts

Sources’ White Rock event one of 130 walkathons across Canada on Feb. 23

Guatemala mission offers hope, health

Peninsula team to visit remote villages, build a home, in Piedra Blanca

MK Delta Lands development another step closer to breaking ground

Delta needs Metro Vancouver’s okay before swapping hundreds of acres and adding it to Burns Bog

VIDEO: A new Hive climbing/fitness facility coming to Surrey in 20,000-sq.-ft. space

‘Bouldering’ and other activities planned at site near Pattullo Bridge

VIDEO: Historic night in Red Deer as 2019 Canada Winter Games kicks off

Star-studded Opening Ceremony features athletes from across Canada

Flying squirrels found to glow pink in the dark, including two from B.C.

Squirrels from Hope and Abbotsford were included in the biologists’ database

Ontario police field complaints over Amber Alert for missing girl, 11, found dead

Some said the Amber Alert issued late Thursday for Riya Rajkumar disrupted their sleep

Northern B.C. First Nation clan says ancient tools found at pipeline work site

Archeologists from the Smithsonian Institute estimate one of the stones found dates back up to 3500 years

Wilson-Raybould resignation stokes anger, frustration within veterans community

Liberals have had three veterans-affairs ministers — Kent Hehr, Seamus O’Regan and Wilson-Raybould

No Center of Gravity festival in Kelowna this summer: organizers

COG organizers said the hope is to return to the Okanagan in 2020

Names keep adding to vaccine petition started by B.C. mom

Maple Ridge mom started campaign to make vaccination a condition of attending school

Eight cases of measles confirmed in Vancouver outbreak

Coastal Health official say the cases stem from the French-language Ecole Jules Verne Secondary

Most Read

l -->