Glen Edward Theriault (inset above) was found guilty this morning of dangerous driving causing death in connection with this Jan. 18

Judge rules dump-truck driver deliberately drove dangerously

Glen Theriault was found guilty Friday of dangerous driving in connection with the head-on crash that killed South Surrey's Jim Neiss.

When dump-truck driver Glen Edward Theriault crossed a double-yellow line nearly three years ago – ultimately killing a South Surrey man in a head-on collision – it was a “conscious, deliberate, risky decision,” a Surrey Provincial Court judge said Friday.

“No reasonable person would even consider driving in the manner the accused did in this case,” Judge Paul Dohm said prior to finding Theriault guilty of dangerous driving causing death in connection with the Jan. 18, 2011 crash that killed 59-year-old Jim Neiss.

“The accused deliberately drove dangerously. The only way the accused could not have seen (headlights of an oncoming vehicle) is if he didn’t look at all.”

Theriault, 65, has been on trial since mid-July. Friday’s verdict was delivered on the 10th day of the proceedings, and brought Neiss’s family and co-workers some consolation.

“I feel relief and vindicated,” Brenda Michie, Neiss’s widow, told Peace Arch News outside court. “The judge did an excellent, thorough job.

“I feel that justice has been served.”

From the trial’s outset, Theriault did not deny that he had driven his westbound truck – which was towing a pup trailer – into the eastbound lane of 16 Avenue over a double-yellow line on the morning in question.

The fatal maneuver, which began in the intersection at 200 Street, was an effort to pass two other westbound vehicles, said Dohm, recounting evidence heard over the course of the trial. When Theriault spotted Neiss’s SUV, he braked and steered to the south side of the road. Neiss steered in the same direction, and the two hit head-on.

Jim NeissThe impact of Theriault’s truck killed Neiss – who was on his way to work as a bus driver for Langley School District at the time – instantly and pushed his SUV 23 metres, Dohm said.

At trial, Dohm heard from five witnesses who described seeing a dump truck being driven aggressively along 16 Avenue for several kilometres prior to the collision, which occurred just after 5:30 a.m. While a number of them testified they were sure it was the same truck that hit Neiss’s – and “they are probably correct” – Dohm said he could not make that finding conclusively.

“It is not logically possible to link their evidence together in some cohesive fashion,” he said. “I’m not able to find to the criminal standards of truth that this was the same dump truck throughout.”

In finding Theriault guilty, Dohm said he relied on evidence regarding the accused’s driving as seen from just east of 200 Street to the point of impact.

In reaching his verdict, he said he also did not consider “utterances” that Theriault had made to police in the hours immediately following the crash.

The court had heard that Theriault told a Langley RCMP officer that his decision to cross the double-yellow line that morning was a “bad, three-second mistake,” and that he had believed at the time the road ahead was clear.

Following a voir dire to determine if Theriault’s charter rights had been violated, Dohm had ruled the statements were admissible.

In explaining his reasoning for ultimately giving them no weight, Dohm noted video and factual evidence regarding the scene make it “very difficult to understand how the accused could’ve believed it was clear to pass.”

“He only had a few seconds, at most, in darkness, to check whether it was clear.”

Streetlights depicted in video taken of the roadway looking west look like two sets of headlights, Dohm said.

“I have decided this case without any regard to utterances found admissible in voir dire,” he said.

Evidence Dohm found relevant included that the type of vehicle Theriault was driving would be more difficult to maneuver, take longer to stop and cause more damage in the event of a crash; that the driving behaviour occurred at a time when commuter and commercial traffic was starting to increase along 16 Avenue; that Theriault’s speed was likely upwards of 75 km/h when he spotted Neiss; and that Theriault chose to ignore the risks associated with crossing a double-yellow line.

“Those lines indicate to a driver that passing is not permissible… not safe, even though that might not be readily apparent,” Dohm said.

“A reasonably prudent driver would never have attempted to pass.”

Prosecutor Winston Sayson told Peace Arch News the verdict was a “well-reasoned decision that confirms the Crown’s submission that the driving of the accused was exceedingly dangerous.”

Michie – who attended court with her sister Maureen Beales and Halimah Simon, one of Neiss’s Langley School District co-workers – said Dohm’s points covered “everything we felt.”

She described her husband as “a colourful, opinionated person” who made her laugh everyday of the 20 years they were together.

“He’d be really pleased today,” she said.

Simon said the verdict renews her faith in the justice system.

“I’ll sleep good tonight,” she said, adding Neiss’s co-workers are “satisfied” with the trial’s outcome.

Theriault did not speak to Peace Arch News, however, a woman who identified herself as his wife, agreed the situation has been difficult for all involved.

“Everybody’s fractured,” she said.

Sentencing is set for Feb. 14.

Brenda Michie and supporters

Just Posted

Minor injuries after South Surrey student struck in school crosswalk

Collision ‘a reminder to drivers, pedestrians to take safety seriously’

Rec centre staff honoured for their help to revive teen who collapsed in weight room

BC Emergency Health Services presented Vital Link awards to four City of Surrey employees on Sunday

Surrey tops list of most delayed, congested TransLink bus routes

TransLink says delays are costing $75 million a year

Once shy, Surrey maker of cakes finds confidence to show skills on TV and at big events

Raveena Oberoi of Just Cakes Bakeshop is a guest speaker at Vancouver Fall Home Show this week

North Delta students collect over 16,000 items during annual one-night food drive

Items collected during Delview Secondary’s annual Thanks 4 Giving benefit Deltassist, Surrey Food Bank

Alberta man pleads guilty, fined for hunting without a licence in North Island

It’s the responsibility of each hunter or angler to know whether they are considered a B.C. Resident.

B.C. mayor apologizes for removal of Queen’s portrait from council chambers

‘I prefer to be inclusive of the many aspects of our history’

Alcohol a possible factor in crash that killed 17-year-old girl near Williams Lake

A pickup truck left the road and rolled over on Highway 20 on the weekend

Rare bird spotted in Victoria draws enthusiasts from across the continent

It’s the first time a yellow-browed warbler has been reported on the mainland of North America

B.C. woman must pay $1,000 after unleashed dog bites another

Owner should never have left Bibi unattended, tribunal member wrote

Climate activist Greta Thunberg’s mural defaced in Edmonton

The eyes on the portrait were blacked out

VIDEO: Depth and scoring lacking for Vancouver Giants this season: Coach

G-Men defeated on home ice Sunday by Victoria – next up Everett on Friday

Report suggests new BC Ferries terminal near YVR

Metro Vancouver currently has two ferry terminals at northern and southern reaches

Most Read

l -->