South Surrey-White Rock-Cloverdale MP Russ Hiebert's controversial bill calling for full disclosure of union financial affairs was the subject of a critical lecture at the University of Regina last week.

Lecture casts shadow on Peninsula MP’s ‘transparency’ bill

Business administration professors say their research traces a relationship between anti-union groups and federal policy makers

MP Russ Hiebert’s controversial private members’ bill calling for full public disclosure of union financial affairs has come in for a detailed and scathing analysis from two professors in the faculty of business administration at the University of Regina.

In a public lecture delivered on campus last Wednesday, Sean Tucker and Andrew Stevens presented evidence they say shows the South Surrey-White Rock-Cloverdale MP’s bill – while touted as wishing to promote greater transparency – seems to be part of a less-than-transparent “anti-union policy agenda” on the part of the federal government.

In the presentation, Working in the Shadows for Transparency: Russ Hiebert, LabourWatch, Nanos Research and the Making of Bill C-377, Tucker and Stevens argue that Hiebert’s amendment to the Income Tax Act shows a clear relationship “between the anti-union business lobby… and federal policy makers.”

And they charge that a flawed poll claiming 83 per cent public support for full disclosure of union finances – and lax regulation in the polling industry itself – call into question the practice of polling to promote public policy.

“We find that the actions of groups and individuals associated with creating, disseminating and reviewing the influential 2011 Nanos Research-LabourWatch poll and promoting C-377, show contempt for the principle of transparency,” Tucker and Stevens write.

Hiebert, first elected in 2004, was not available for comment by Peace Arch News’ press deadline on Friday. Last February, he announced he would not seek a fifth term.

After receiving a rough ride in the Senate last year, including flak from Conservative senators who broke ranks with the government to claim the legislation is “unconstitutional,” Hiebert’s bill was returned to the House of Commons this year  – a result of Prime Minister Stephen Harper’s prorogation (postponement) of Parliament deliberations in September 2013.

It has since passed in the House and is currently at second reading before the Senate.

Tucker maintained Thursday his focus on C-377 has not been politically motivated. It has been a “rabbit hole,” he said, that first opened when he was asked to contribute to a CBC open-line radio program on the bill three years ago.

But Tucker said his examination of the 2011 Nanos poll, sponsored by LabourWatch, found that some questions had been “primed” to produce responses, and that answers to one question – which would have contradicted the poll findings – had been left out.

“I did bring this to Mr. Hiebert’s attention in 2011, but he never acknowledged my letter,” he said.

This is not the first time the academics’ work has raised questions about the poll; their research was cited last year by the Canadian Labour Congress in a complaint to the Marketing Research and Intelligence Association. The complaint was subsequently dismissed by an MRIA review panel that found the poll did not violate association standards, though noting it had released “potentially biased information” on public attitudes toward unions’ disclosure of financial affairs.

Tucker said changes to the poll report urged by the panel were not adopted by LabourWatch.

In their lecture, Tucker and Stevens cited an opinion on the poll questions from  UBC professor Richard Johnson, Canada Research Chair in Public Opinion, Elections and Representation.

“You’re asking people to endorse openness,” he told them. “Well who’s against that?…I suspect that if you asked exactly the same question about corporations, it may not be 83 per cent, but I bet you it would be pretty one-sided.”

Tucker said he finds it particularly significant that the Nanos poll appeared just before Hiebert presented the first version of his bill.

“It’s unclear why Mr. Hiebert should be the author of C-377,” he said, adding he finds it “hard to believe” that the drafting of the bill was solely an initiative of the MP.

“Evidence suggests that C-377 is the product of two ideological anti-union organizations: LabourWatch and Merit Canada,” he said.

“LabourWatch is an organization that polls Canadians on a regular basis, aiming at putting labour unions in a bad light – it’s a shotgun approach in which they ask a whole bunch of questions to build up a case, and that political pressure has to go somewhere.

“The question is, do we want public policy shaped by ideological lobby groups?”

He also questioned why Hiebert would refer to LabourWatch as a “non-partisan” organization – in a news release on the poll quoted in a 2013 PAN article –  when the organization’s own website suggests otherwise.

Tucker pointed to an email from  LabourWatch president John Mortimer to Labour Minister Lisa Raitt on the eve of a 2012 vote on C-377 in the House of Commons.

“I am in Ottawa for this important day for the conservative movement and for Canadian taxpayers,” Mortimer writes, in an email obtained in a freedom-of-information request.



Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Washington State Department of Agriculture workers, wearing protective suits and working vacuumed a nest of Asian giant hornets from a tree Saturday, Oct. 24, 2020, in Blaine, Wash. Scientists in Washington state discovered the first nest earlier in the week of so-called murder hornets in the United States and worked to wipe it out Saturday morning to protect native honeybees. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson)
Nest of ‘murder hornets’ found near South Surrey

String of traps set up along border to capture Asian giant hornets

Loretta Hibbs (right), founder and president of Surrey-based City Dream Centre, with Kelly Voros (foreground), the organization's executive administrator. (submitted photo)
‘Pumpkin patch’ brought to Surrey inner-city schools where COVID cancelled field trips

Work done by volunteers with Surrey-based City Dream Centre

B.C.’s Court of Appeal is in Vancouver. (File photo: Tom Zytaruk)
Judgment reserved in Surrey Six slayings appeals

Six men were killed in suite 1505 of the Balmoral Tower in Whalley on Oct. 19, 2007

File photo
Hundreds of Canadian chambers support Surrey Board of Trade’s call for pension fix

Up to 12 million Canadian workers don’t have pension plans other than CPP

Tyler Joe Miller. (submitted photo)
Record-setting second hit song for Surrey’s Tyler Joe Miller, who’s ‘stoked for what’s next’

I Would Be Over Me Too song follows Pillow Talkin’ up the country charts

Carolyn and Steve Touhey came across a pod of humpback whales while on their boat Sunday, Oct. 25. Photo supplied
VIDEO: Boaters encounter pod of humpbacks in Georgia Strait

Pod spotted between Comox and Texada Island

It’s been eight years since Gordon Spencer (pictured), and cousin, ‘Lil’ Bruce Mayo, were gunned down in a home in Langley, and Spencer’s widow is hoping someone who knows something will step up (file)
Eight years on and still no answers in Langley double murder

Wife of victim makes public appeal for people with information to come forward

Langley resident Sean Nugent, who died in 2019 shortly he saved a swimmer from drowning, has been awarded a posthumous medal for bravery by the Royal Canadian Humane Association (Courtesy Nugent family)
Langley man who died after saving swimmer receives posthumous medal for bravery

Sean Nugent rescued woman from Hayward Lake near Mission in July of 2019

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau provides an update on the COVID pandemic during a press conference in Ottawa on Tuesday, Oct. 27, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Trudeau says pandemic ‘really sucks,’ and that Christmas gatherings are up in the air

The prime minister encouraged residents to continue to follow the advice of local health authorities

Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

Join Black Press Media and Do Some Good

Pay it Forward program supports local businesses in their community giving

The Williams Lake Indian Band is stipulating no-go zones for mushroom picking in areas burned by last summer’s wildfires. 100 Mile Free Press photo
Who controls mushroom harvesting on Indigenous lands?

‘We don’t necessarily know where the mushrooms grow, how old the stands need to be, those types of things.’

Canadian and American flags fly near the Ambassador Bridge at the Canada/USA border crossing in Windsor, Ont. on Saturday, March 21, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Rob Gurdebeke
U.S. election results one factor that could impact immigration to Canada next year

The survey polled 1,523 Canadians between Oct. 23 and Oct. 25

Most Read