Unlike the Deltaport coal terminal (pictured)

Surrey business groups divided on coal trains

South Surrey & White Rock Chamber of Commerce touts 'quality of life'; Surrey Board of Trade supports 'economic argument.'

The South Surrey & White Rock Chamber of Commerce is taking a stance against a controversial new coal-export terminal proposed by Fraser Surrey Docks – and particularly the increase in coal-train traffic through White Rock and South Surrey that would result.

Chamber executive director Cliff Annable told Peace Arch News Wednesday that the result of board deliberations this week is that the organization is not supporting the coal terminal.

“The point of view of the board is that we don’t want the (additional) coal trains through White Rock and South Surrey,” Annable said, adding the board had “discussed this at length.”

He noted the decision differs markedly from the Surrey Board of Trade’s position.

Annable said he was surprised by remarks attributed to SBOT CEO Anita Huberman, who told Black Press: “We have to stop saying ‘no’ to everything, and that’s what I think is happening sometimes in South Surrey.”

The South Surrey & White Rock Chamber is not trying to be obstructionist, Annable said.

“We don’t have a problem with Fraser Surrey Docks as a business – we’re a business organization,” he said. “But what goes with business is the quality of life.”

Huberman had said last week that she had hoped the two business groups could have adopted a unified position by that point.

Huberman said she was pressing other stakeholder and business groups to support the new terminal, and that Surrey council – which has so far been noncommittal – should make a firm stand in favour.

“Yes, the environment is important… The economic argument for us is the winner,” she said.

Annable said opposition to the increased coal traffic in the community – including at a waterfront rally March 17 that was attended by Surrey-White Rock Liberal MLA Gordon Hogg, White Rock Mayor Wayne Baldwin and Couns. Helen Fathers (White Rock)  and Barinder Rasode (Surrey) – has been well noted.

“The number of people who are concerned about it in White Rock and South Surrey is significant,’ Annable said, adding the chamber has also heard concerns from Crescent Beach residents over safety and reduced access due to increased train traffic.

Annable noted Metro is doing an environmental assessment of the proposal before considering granting an air-emissions permit.

“I don’t know, personally, how bad the coal dust is for you, but if the Americans in Washington and Oregon say they don’t want it, why would we have it here?” he said.

Annable, a former member of White Rock council, said he has “never seen an issue that is as divisive and controversial as this coal thing – people, whether yea or nay, are passionate about it.

“But the position of the board, right now, is we don’t want the trains.”

 

 

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Comments are closed

Just Posted

Surrey city staff hears restricting recovery homes to six clients won’t cut it

Corporate report notes there are more recovery homes in Surrey than in every other community in B.C. combined

South Surrey’s Historic Stewart Farm to offer guided tours

Outdoor tours to run afternoons Tuesdays through Fridays

Surrey Food Bank opens huge new ‘forever home’ in Newton

New warehouse on 78th Avenue is close to three times the size of the food bank’s old site in Whalley

Semiahmoo Peninsula girls to host Black Lives Matter fundraiser

‘We are doing this because the world is full of systemic racism,’ organizer Sabine Lapointe said

Community fruit harvest program returns to Surrey, White Rock

Sources will send a team to harvest fruit trees, so less goes to waste

Following incident at sea, fishing lodge says it will reopen despite Haida travel ban

QCL reopens July 10, says president; Haida chief councillor describes ‘dangerous’ boating encounter

Kamloops RCMP officer’s conduct under review after blackface jokes on social media

Meinke’s Instagram is private and it’s unclear when the posts were made

NHL says 35 players have tested positive for COVID-19 since June 8

Positive rate for the league is just under 6%

Man charged in Rideau Hall crash had rifle, shotguns, high-capacity magazine: RCMP

Hurren is accused of threatening to cause death or bodily harm to the prime minister

B.C. extends income assistance exemption for COVID-19

Provincial program to match Ottawa’s CERB, student pay

Most Read

l -->