Homeowners have rights

Editor:

Re: The pub was here first, Oct. 3 letters.

Editor:

Re: The pub was here first, Oct. 3 letters.

I respect the opinions of letter-writer Russell Marshall, but I have a problem with his suggestions.

He admits the pub is a source of annoyance to neighbours who have to put up with the fights, garbage and noise. His solution: If you don’t like it, move out to sea where you may be disturbed by the whales.

This shows a lack of concern and respect for the legitimate rights of homeowners to not be subjected to fights, garbage and noise. According to the original letter to PAN (Chaos at closing time, Sept. 24), homeowners sustain sleepless nights from the chaos which goes on till 2 a.m. This results in constant calls to police, who can only do so much.

Marshall’s main point seems to be the pub was here first, and he suggests this implies a special status for patrons to have a good time and asks that homeowners be tolerant in this situation. There are no legal grounds to support this argument.

In fact, there is precedent in tort law that recognizes that landowners have the right to the reasonable comfort and convenience in occupying their land.

Under the law, loud noises are recognized as an example of a private nuisance. Legal remedy and civil liability is determined by the courts, and all mitigating circumstances on both sides are considered.

Some readers may remember a few years ago, a private nuisance case from this area was settled in favour of the plaintiff. In this case, people moved close to a mushroom farm and objected to the continual smell without success. Legal action followed, but I am not sure if the case actually went to court.

Charles Parrott, Surrey

 

 

Just Posted

Body still inside Surrey building two days after fire due to structural concerns

RCMP, fire investigations delayed ‘until the site is declared safe’

Surrey cop killer gets new parole conditions

Surrey RCMP Constable Roger Pierlet, 23, was shot dead on March 29, 1974

Theft of dog-outfits ‘a huge hit’ to South Surrey mother-daughter business

Kathy Neumeyer says 100-plus dog sweaters and raincoats were nicked from her SUV last week

Game-worn rugby jerseys auctioned in Surrey club’s ‘Ruck for the Cure’ fundraiser

Benefit for cancer society at Sullivan Heights Park and Beaverlodge clubhouse Saturday

OUR VIEW: Foreigners need to butt out of our elections

Canadians don’t need outsiders to tell us who to vote for

VIDEO: Is the stethoscope dying? High-tech options pose threat

World-renowned cardiologist believes the device is just a pair of ‘rubber tubes’

VIDEO: Chill with polar bears through an Arctic live cam

Cam reopens just ahead of Polar Bear Week

UPDATE: Charges pending after two teens pepper sprayed at Port Coquitlam high school

Mounties are still working to determine exactly how many youth were involved

Aquilini companies deny negligence in U.S. vineyard fire that killed two kids

Fire occurred at Red Mountain Vineyard, located in southeast Washington State

Former Kelowna Hells Angels associate could be deported, court rules

David Revell has lost his fight against deportation from Canada

Witness of Abbotsford shooting recounts terrifying experience

He describes being caught between the gunmen and their intended target

Alcohol available onboard BC Ferries starting Thursday

Beer and wine sales begin at 11 a.m. on select Tsawwassen-Swartz Bay sailings

Olympian Brent Hayden returning to competition after seven years away

The 36-year-old has been training in Vancouver for several weeks

Most Read

l -->