Vimy didn’t inspire then

Editor:

Re: An international lesson in Canadian history, Nov. 3.

I enjoyed Earl Marriott Secondary student Stephanie Nowak’s comments.

Editor:

Re: An international lesson in Canadian history, Nov. 3.

I enjoyed Earl Marriott Secondary student Stephanie Nowak’s comments about Canada’s involvement in Europe in the First World War.

I would like to make a few remarks. First, Winston Churchill was not the prime minister at that time; he was First Lord of the Admiralty.

Second, was Vimy a watershed moment in Canadian identity?

Victory on the ridge notwithstanding, Canadian prime minister Robert Borden was convinced the fate of the British empire was in jeopardy and promised London more soldiers.

Conscription was the issue in the 1917 election, and Borden would tolerate no opposition to his policy.

So certain recent immigrants, their loyalty suspect, were disenfranchised, and the vote given to mothers and wives of serving soldiers. There was even a scheme to put overseas soldiers’ votes into handpicked ridings.

Significant resistance confronted conscription all across Canada. Ontario farmers marched on Ottawa, demanding exemptions for their sons, and riots broke out in Quebec.

As it turned out, conscription failed to produce significantly more recruits than voluntarism, and even by 1918 almost half of the Canadian Expeditionary Force was still British-born.

Whatever its virtues, Vimy did not provide inspiration for the commitment and sacrifice needed to get more men in the trenches any more than “imperial patriotism” did.

Space and time may prevent many from visiting the Vimy memorial, yet I wonder how comfortable Canadians are in accepting a blood-and-guts battle as a foundation of their national identity.

Bob Burgel, Surrey

 

Just Posted

Surrey MLA says EHT tax causing police funding cuts

Marvin Hunt says Employer Health Tax is ‘hammering’ schools, hospitals, law enforcement

Vancouver police officer from Surrey charged with sexual assault

Jagraj Roger Berar, 51, of Surrey, charged in incident alleged to have happened in Whistler

Help Delta Heritage Society learn more about items in its collection

DHS is reviewing its collection to prepare for the opening of the new Delta Cultural Centre

VIDEO: Surrey mayor decries ‘alarming frequency’ of ‘mob violence’ after another brawl

Surrey RCMP urge the public to come forward with information about those involved

Falling tree crushes front of SUV carrying South Surrey woman, granddaughters

City confirms ‘failure’ has triggered risk assessment of Croydon Drive trees

VIDEO: Disney Plus adds disclaimer about racist stereotypes

Disney’s disclaimer is a good way to begin discussion about the larger issue of racism

B.C. woman seeks return of jewelry box containing father’s cremated remains

Sicamous RCMP report handmade box was stolen from a storage locker

CN Rail confirms job cuts as weakening economy cuts into freight volumes

Railroad also said it was affected by a slowdown in the B.C.’s forestry sector

Port Alberni mom takes school district to court over Indigenous smudging, prayer in class

Candice Servatius, who is an evangelical Christian, is suing School District 70

New case of vaping-related illness in Quebec brings national total to 8

Quebec health minister considering tightening the rules around vaping products

Greens to vote against Liberal throne speech unless carbon targets toughened: May

Green leader Elizabeth May and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau met Friday, discussing common ground

Toxic smell returns to Abbotsford elementary school raising health concerns for students, teachers and parents

King Traditional Elementary suffers daily from neighbouring waste-storage facility’s stench

First Nations ‘optimistic’ about road upgrades after Horgan visits site of fatal bus crash

Premier travelled Bamfield Main road, where bus flipped last September and two students were killed

Delays seen on some Metro Vancouver bus routes as transit strike ramps up

According to TransLink, routes in downtown Vancouver are bearing the brunt of the delays

Most Read

l -->