City of Surrey this month has hosted a roving display of a sample LRT car. Friday, it moved to Newton’s Superstore parking lot. (Amy Reid photo)

LETTERS: Hardly too late to reverse course

Editor: Re: SkyTrain-LRT debate only over for one leg, May 9 letters.


Re: SkyTrain-LRT debate only over for one leg, May 9 letters.

Your columnist Frank Bucholtz is far off the mark when he says that it is too late to change from LRT for Phase 1 of the Surrey Rapid Transit project.

It is never too late to avoid making an appallingly bad decision.

The sunk costs to date will be nothing compared to the ongoing losses that will result from building LRT. A November 2017 University of Calgary School of Public Policy study concluded LRT Phase 1 would have a net present value of -$510 million, in 2010 dollars. In other words, it will destroy nearly half a billion dollars of value in Surrey. That study was done before the recent massive increases in estimated cost of the LRT project.

Bucholtz correctly notes that land acquisition was the major driver of those cost increases, but doesn’t see the obvious corollary: to keep costs in line, LRT will require reducing King George Boulevard to two lanes, as it was 90 years ago when Surrey had a population less than one per cent of its current population.

LRT construction costs may be marginally lower than SkyTrain, but this will be more than offset by immensely higher operating costs:

• LRT cars require a driver, which SkyTrain does not, and personnel costs are usually one of the fastest-growing cost components.

• Having a different vehicle and track will mean much higher costs of procurement, since the volume will be far lower than adding another 50 cars to a large SkyTrain order.

• It will not be possible to use the existing SkyTrain maintenance facility in Burnaby, which means additional capital costs to acquire a site for an LRT-only maintenance shop, and constructing and running that facility.

• Operating procedures, security systems and staff training will all be completely different, resulting in much higher operating costs.

The result is entirely predictable: LRT will be the unwanted orphan of TransLink. Being a Surrey-only system, it will quickly become a Surrey-only cost, leading to immensely higher property taxes on Surrey residents.

Ed Beauregard, Surrey

Just Posted

Whalley falls in first game of Little League World Series

Team Canada goes down to powerful Panama in Williamsport

Surrey looks to target illegal dumpers with surveillance cameras

Since 2007, illegal dumping has cost the City of Surrey more than $8.5 million dollars

White Rock’s Mia Pedersen enters council race

Teacher will run as independent

Peacock trapping to commence in early September, says City of Surrey

Since plan approved in June, bylaw has focused on ensuring people no longer feed the birds, ahead of relocation

Downtown Surrey BIA announces all-candidates meetings

BIA plans three events for civic candidates this September, ahead of the Oct. 20 election

PHOTOS: B.C. city wakes up to darkness under wildfire smoke

The rest of the province also dealing with thick haze as smoky skies continue

VIDEO: World of Magic coming to Vancouver

Seven magic shows will appear at the Vancouver Playhouse from September 7 to 9

Safeway union urges prejection of mediator recommendations

Says mediator asks for too many concessions

Fire chases B.C. crews out of their own camp

Crews in Burns Lake had to leave after a wildfire reportedly overtook their sleeping quarters

VIDEO: RibFest kicks off in Langley

Free event features barbecue ribs, chicken, pork and brisket from Canada’s top rib artists

Hospitals to see ‘delays’ in care after losing Saudi students, health group says

About 1,000 Saudi residents called back to kingdom after suspending diplomatic relations with Canada

Bernier diatribe against ‘extreme multiculturalism’ boosts Liberal coffers

Party spokesperson Braeden Caley says online donations doubled, social media engagement quadrupled

‘Disjointed’ system hinders British Columbia First Nations in wildfire fight

More than 550 wildfires were burning in B.C. and crews were bracing for wind and dry lightning

Castlegar bridge designed by architect of collapsed Italian bridge

Riccardo Morandi designed the Kinnaird Bridge, which is part of Highway 3.

Most Read

l -->