City of Surrey this month has hosted a roving display of a sample LRT car. Friday, it moved to Newton’s Superstore parking lot. (Amy Reid photo)

LETTERS: Hardly too late to reverse course

Editor: Re: SkyTrain-LRT debate only over for one leg, May 9 letters.


Re: SkyTrain-LRT debate only over for one leg, May 9 letters.

Your columnist Frank Bucholtz is far off the mark when he says that it is too late to change from LRT for Phase 1 of the Surrey Rapid Transit project.

It is never too late to avoid making an appallingly bad decision.

The sunk costs to date will be nothing compared to the ongoing losses that will result from building LRT. A November 2017 University of Calgary School of Public Policy study concluded LRT Phase 1 would have a net present value of -$510 million, in 2010 dollars. In other words, it will destroy nearly half a billion dollars of value in Surrey. That study was done before the recent massive increases in estimated cost of the LRT project.

Bucholtz correctly notes that land acquisition was the major driver of those cost increases, but doesn’t see the obvious corollary: to keep costs in line, LRT will require reducing King George Boulevard to two lanes, as it was 90 years ago when Surrey had a population less than one per cent of its current population.

LRT construction costs may be marginally lower than SkyTrain, but this will be more than offset by immensely higher operating costs:

• LRT cars require a driver, which SkyTrain does not, and personnel costs are usually one of the fastest-growing cost components.

• Having a different vehicle and track will mean much higher costs of procurement, since the volume will be far lower than adding another 50 cars to a large SkyTrain order.

• It will not be possible to use the existing SkyTrain maintenance facility in Burnaby, which means additional capital costs to acquire a site for an LRT-only maintenance shop, and constructing and running that facility.

• Operating procedures, security systems and staff training will all be completely different, resulting in much higher operating costs.

The result is entirely predictable: LRT will be the unwanted orphan of TransLink. Being a Surrey-only system, it will quickly become a Surrey-only cost, leading to immensely higher property taxes on Surrey residents.

Ed Beauregard, Surrey

Just Posted

Team BC defeats its hosts at junior curling nationals Sunday

Tyler Tardi and his team have played and won three games in the Canadian championships, so far.

UPDATE: Olympic softball qualifier to be held in Surrey

Tournament is to be held Aug. 25 to Sept. 1

Surrey resident to speak about erasing Alzheimer’s disease stigma

A goal of Dona McMorland is to erase stigma attached to the disease

Vehicle rollover in Surrey

Surrey Fire Service responded to the collision on the 19500-block of 60 Avenue

VIDEO: Three-peat for Semiahmoo at basketball’s Surrey RCMP Classic

South Surrey-based squad tops Lord Tweedsmuir in final at Enver Creek gym

REPLAY: B.C’s best videos this week

In case you missed it, here’s a look at the replay-worth highlights from this week across the province

Patriots make 3rd straight Super Bowl, beat Chiefs 37-31 in OT

New England will meet L.A. Rams in NFL title game

Pettersson returns to lead Canucks to 3-2 win over Red Wings

Vancouver’s super rookie has 2 points in first game back after knee injury

Crash closes Coquihalla southbound lane south of Merritt

Accident occurred approximately 26 kilometres south of Merritt

Skaters stranded in Saint John, NB, amid storm on last day of championships

More than half of the flights out of the city’s airport were cancelled due to the weather

Call for tighter bail rules after Saudi sex-crime suspect vanishes

Mohammed Zuraibi Alzoabi was facing charges related to alleged sexual assault, criminal harassment, assault and forcible confinement of a woman

12 poisoned eagles found on Vancouver Island

Improper disposal of euthanized animal suspected

B.C. resident creates global sport training program

The 20 hour course teaches the science and application of interval training at the university level

B.C. VIEWS: Fact-checking the NDP’s speculation tax on empty homes

Negative-option billing is still legal for governments

Most Read

l -->